8th March 2013

GRAND PRIX des NATIONS - Geneva

FANGIO BENEFITS FROM TARUFFI'S MISFORTUNE

It was Piero Taruffi's first drive for the Alfa Romeo team and from the front row of the grid he led comfortably from the start until the 62nd of the 68 laps. Then the brakes failed and the car left the road and the race. Thus Juan Fangio inherited an easy albeit undeserved victory.

ENTRY

The Grand Prix des Nations at the Geneva circuit near the beautiful lake seems to have been viewed as one of the more important non-Championship races of the season. Emphasizing that point was the arrival of four factory Alfa Romeos. Alongside regular drivers Farina and Fangio were two guests. As at the Swiss Grand Prix Toulo de Graaffenried was granted a drive while the fourth car was entrusted to Ferrari factory driver Piero Taruffi. This seems to have been a late entry as it had the last number on the entry list while the other three cars had the first three. Ferrari brought only two cars this time, for Ascari and Villoresi, appearing perhaps not to take the race quite as seriously as the team from Turin. The two OSCAs in existence both arrived - the works car for Franco Rol and Prince Bira in his blue and yellow version.

Maseratis were there in large numbers - eight of the 4.CLTs, to be exact. Froilan Gonzales had the light blue and yellow Argentine team car, while David Murray brought his green version from Scotland. The rest were red; Toni Branca was given a drive in de Graffenried's usual car while the Milano cars were there in the hands of Bonetto and Gianfranco Comotti. Chiron, Schell and Reg Parnell made up the remainder of the Modena entry.

The rest of the 20 car entry was French. A rather smaller proportion than usual with only three Talbots (Sommer, Claes and Giraud-Cabantous) and a lone Gordini for Robert Manzon. Quite why drivers like Rosier, Etancelin and Trintignant were absent is open to conjecture.

PRACTICE

It was quite a surprise to see Ascari's Ferrari at the top of the list after the first of two practice sessions, but an even bigger surprise when he went even quicker in the second session and took pole position by three-tenths of a second from the Alfas of Taruffi and Fangio. The Italian, in his first drive this season in an Alfa Romeo, was revelling in the speed and handling of the car. Gonzales did an excellent job with the blue and yellow Maserati, getting ahead of the two other Alfas and Villoresi's Ferrari. The burly Argentine was truly competitive and looked forward to a strong race. Farina was a little off the pace this time and did not look his usual confident self. Ferrari, Alfa and Maserati shared the third row with Villoresi, de Graffenried and Chiron, who was back in his regular Maserati. The ever-improving Gordini of Manzon was actually halfway up the grid. So much better than it's usual back row spot from months ago.

The two OSCAs sandwiched two Maseratis; Bira being the quicker of the OSCAs but rather disappointed not to be further up the grid. David Murray went really well to be fourth quickest of the eight Maseratis and just ahead of the much higher rated Harry Schell's similar car. The last six on the grid showed alternate Talbots and Maseratis. Seeing Sommer so far back was quite surprising but at least he was ahead of Giraud's and Claes' similar cars. Reg Parnell had some engine issues in practice and wound up at the back.

Here is the full grid order the 68 lap race:

   1.
40
A. ASCARI FERRARI 375
1.46'70
   2.
46
P. TARUFFI ALFA ROMEO 158
1.47'05
   3.
4
J. FANGIO ALFA ROMEO 158
1.47'19
   4.
8
F. GONZALES MASERATI 4.CLT
1.47'31
   5.
2
N. FARINA ALFA ROMEO 158
1.47'70
   6.
42
L. VILLORESI FERRARI 375
1.47'73
   7.
6
E. de GRAFFENRIED ALFA ROMEO 158
1.48'61
   8.
10
L. CHIRON MASERATI 4.CLT
1.49'46
   9.
20
F. BONETTO MASERATI 4.CLT
1.50'31
  10.
24
R. MANZON GORDINI T.15
1.50'53
  11.
30
B. BIRA OSCA
1.50'56
  12.
36
D. MURRAY MASERATI 4.CLT
1.50'59
  13.
32
H. SCHELL MASERATI 4.CLT
1.50'60
  14.
12
F. ROL OSCA
1.51'36
  15.
44
R. SOMMER TALBOT LAGO T.26C
1.51'62
  16.
26
A. BRANCA MASERATI 4.CLT
1.52'05
  17.
16
Y. GIRAUD-CABANTOUS TALBOT LAGO T.26C
1.52'85
  18.
22
G. COMOTTI MASERATI 4.CLT
1.53'45
  19.
18
J. CLAES TALBOT LAGO T.26C
1.53'66
  20.
34
R. PARNELL MASERATI 4.CLT
1.54'31

THE RACE

From the centre of the front row of the grid Piero Taruffi led the twenty cars away and much to everyone's surprise he simply drove away from the field with apparent ease. By lap 10 he was 11 seconds clear of Farina and Gonzales, who was doing a brilliant job in the Argentine Maserati. Fangio had made a cautious start and was down in 5th place behind Ascari. De Graffenried had Villoresi behind him and the second Ferrari was followed by several Maseratis and Bira's OSCA with Sommer's Talbot being the first non-Italian cars in 12th place. Farina continued in 2nd as the race approached its middle stages but he spun out of the race on lap 32 under pressure from Fangio who had moved smoothly up to 3rd. Ascari had begun to suffer handling problem (again) and several cars passed him so that by lap 20 he was down to 7th. Following the retirement of Farina's Alfa Fangio had settled down in 2nd place but offered no threat whatsoever to his occasional team-mate out front. The gap between the two Alfas settled to around 30 seconds and Juan Manuel made no effort to reduce the difference. What was not realised was that Taruffi's brakes were beginning to fade - the big stop at the hairpin putting great strain on the retardation properties of the Alfa. Sadly for Piero, the lack of brakes caught him out at the tight right-hander at the end of the longest straight and the car ran off the road and into retirement only six laps from the finish. It was a very disappointing end to a first class drive. Thus Fangio was able to cruise in to win yet another race although he was the first to admit that it had been a fortunate victory.

Gonzales had driven quite beautifully and was a thoroughly deserved second man home with 'local boy' Toulo de Graffenried making it home in 3rd. Ascari was a dispirited 4th and is getting rather tired of his car's lack of competitiveness. At least he finished, unlike his team-mate Villoresi who retired with braking problems on lap 29. The race saw a large number of retirements, with neither OSCA making it to the end along with Manzon's Gordini which, following his excellent practice effort, lastest but 6 laps before electrical problems halted the little car. Neither Chiron, Schell nor Comotti made it to half way with their Maseratis but Bonetto worked his way up to 6th before going out on lap 43. Toni Branca was the best of the rest Maserati-wise, with Sommer and Giraud's Talbots separating him from Murray and Parnell who brought up the rear of the nine finishers in their 4.CLTs - Murray being delighted to finish ahead of Parnell.

Here is the full result of the 68 lap race:


   1.
4
J. FANGIO ALFA ROMEO 158
2.04.00'02
   2.
8
F. GONZALES MASERATI 4.CLT
2.04.46'17
   3.
6
E. de GRAFFENRIED ALFA ROMEO 158
2.04.46'91
   4.
40
A. ASCARI FERRARI 375
67 laps
   5.
26
A. BRANCA MASERATI 4.CLT
66 laps
   6.
44
R. SOMMER TALBOT LAGO T.26
66 laps
   7.
16
Y. GIRAUD-CABANTOUS TALBOT LAGO T.26
65 laps
   8.
36
D. MURRAY MASERATI 4.CLT
65 laps
   9.
34
R. PARNELL MASERATI 4.CLT
64 laps
Fastest lap:   P. TARUFFI, ALFA ROMEO 158,   on lap 47,   1.43'47

Retired:
 
46
P. TARUFFI ALFA ROMEO 158
62 laps
 
20
F. BONETTO MASERATI 4.CLT
42 laps
 
2
N. FARINA ALFA ROMEO 158
31 laps
 
32
H. SCHELL MASERATI 4.CLT
28 laps
 
42
L. VILLORESI FERRARI 375
28 laps
 
10
L. CHIRON MASERATI 4.CLT
27 laps
 
22
G. COMOTTI MASERATI 4.CLT
14 laps
 
18
J. CLAES TALBOT LAGO T.26C
14 laps
 
30
B. BIRA OSCA
13 laps
 
24
R. MANZON GORDINI T.15
6 laps
 
12
F. ROL OSCA
3 laps

Go here if you wish to find out more about my Titans series.

Back to my home page.