13.4.2012

TROPHEE d'AUVERGNE - Clermont-Ferrand

JACK LEWIS' GREATEST DAY

It's said that every dog will have his day. That's certainly true in the case of Jack Lewis who, on this most difficult of all the circuits that the F.2 teams visit, matched and then beat Stirling Moss in a straight fight. A remarkable performance.

A notable absentee for this race around the twists and turns of the Charade circuit in the Massif Centrale was Jack Brabham who opted to miss this event with his self-run Cooper. Otherwise it was a similar entry to that from the previous two French races at Reims and Rouen. Coopers make up the majority of the entry as always, Moss and Trintignant in the Walker cars, McLaren and Gregory in the semi-works cars, Bueb and Bristow in the B.R.P Borgward powered machines, Gendebien and Pillette with the two Belgian cars and Parnell and Henry Taylor with Reg Parnell's cars made up the two car teams with single cars for Schell, Marsh, Lewis, Burgess, Campbell-Jones and newcomer Edgar Berney driving a Cooper owned by Bernard Collomb.

The other five cars on the entry consist of three Lotus - just one of which is a works car for Graham Hill while Bruce Halford has his Fisher-owned Sixteen and the ever optimistic Bob Hicks once again brings along his old Twelve. Jean Behra will drive his own Behra Porsche this time, while Carel de Beaufort is down to drive one of the central seat RSK Porsches.

PRACTICE

Quite why Jack Lewis and his T.45 Cooper found such speed at this particular circuit is simply a mystery; it seems that everything just clicked into place and the car was clearly working beautifully especially through the twisty fist half of the lap but it was still quite a surprise to see the west country man's name at the top of the time sheets at the end of both practice sessions. Lewis' best lap was eight tenths of a second quicker than Stirling Moss' best giving Lewis is first pole position of the season. Bruce McLaren put his Cooper on the front row but he was not confident that he could maintain the position once the race started. Graham Hill changed cars between practice sessions, a luxury he was able to take advantage of as there was no second car entered. The car he drove in the second session went very well enabling Graham to leapfrog up to 4th. Sharing row 2 with Hill's Lotus was Maurice Trintignant in the second Walker Cooper. The quickest Frenchman was concerned with the fact that the front of the car was bottoming out all the way around the circuit, making him feel very uncomfortable.

Bristow, Halford and Gregory shared row 3, the Cooper drivers feeling somewhat disgruntled with cats that really gave them no confidence whatsoever, while Halford was very much more gruntled as his Lotus was working beautifully and giving him a very nice ride indeed. It was a surpise to see Jean Behra so far back and Andre Pillette so far forward, given the relative performances of the two cars in previous races. Behra was confident that he would be able to move forward in the race. Equipe National Belge produced a brand new chassis for Gendebien to replace the 45 uprated to 51 car he has driven before. The new car did not move Olivier as far forward as the team had hoped and the Belgian was on row 6 with Harry Schell whose Cooper looked to be very fast but was simply not handling well enough through the twists and turns of this difficult circuit. The other two non-Coopers went well enough to get ahead of four of the other Coopers with de Beaufort and Hicks both doing a solid job with there unfashionable cars.

THE RACE - 30 laps

Although Jack Lewis had been fastest in practice, few expected the race to turn out as it did. Indeed, as Stirling Moss leaped into the lead from the start it was presumed that the die was cast and the race would be for second. The lap at Clermont-Ferrand is almost four minutes long, yet after five of those long laps the gap between Moss and Lewis was still only 3 seconds. Over the next five this stretched to 12 but that's as big as it got and Lewis, finding the handling of his getting better and better suddenly begun to lap faster than Moss to such an extent that by lap 15 the very dark green Cooper was ahead of the dark blue one. The gap was 5 seconds but 5 laps later Moss was back in the lead by 5 seconds himself. This stretched out to 10 with just 5 laps to go and the feeling was that Lewis was about to finish second to Stirling for the second race in succession. But not a bit of it... It was obvious that Moss was struggling with the handling, the car sliding on the corners, of which there are no less than 36 on this track. Lewis required no second chance. He took a couple of seconds a lap away from Stirling's lead and as they went into their final lap Jack was but a second behind and there was an inevitability about the outcome. Sure enough, as the cars came back into view across the valley it was the dark one with the broad white stripe ahead of the dark one with the white nose band. One and a half seconds was the gap at the end and Jack Lewis had achieved a remarkable and unforgettable victory.

By lap 6 Graham Hill had moved into 3rd place and although he could not match the pace of the two Coopers ahead of him the Lotus was much quicker than anyone else and he had a quiet, lonely race in that 3rd place. An interesting duel lasted all race between the two French heroes with Trintignant initially leading Behra but Jeannot overtook the Cooper on lap 17 and beat Maurice by 10 seconds in the end. The final place in the top six went to Bruce McLaren who had a very difficult race with an ill-handling Cooper. In fact it seems that most of the Coopers in this race had handling troubles, Several drivers stopped prematurely rather than risk an accident on this challenging circuit. The exceptions were Lewis and the two Parnell cars all three of which handled beautifully although Henry Taylor lost his brakes just two laps from the end.

Bob Hicks spun his old Lotus off the road early on and de Beaufort had a fairly sizeable accident in one of the faster sections of the circuit but without personal damage. Both Belgian Coopers retired, Pillette very early while Gendebien had a steady race but stopped when the new Cooper's bodywork came loose. A word should be said for Edgar Berney who drove exuberantly and made it to the finish, ahead of Burgess in his rather slow Cooper.

HERE IS THE FULL RESULT OF THE 30 LAP RACE:

1.
24
J. LEWIS COOPER CLIMAX T.45     1. 57. 20'48
2.
14
S. MOSS COOPER BORGWARD T.51     1. 57. 21'97
3.
38
G. HILL LOTUS CLIMAX 16     1. 58. 11'23
4.
28
J. BEHRA BEHRA PORSCHE     1. 58. 56'78
5.
16
M. TRINTIGNANT COOPER CLIMAX T.51     1. 59. 06'43
6.
40
B. MCLAREN COOPER CLIMAX T.51     2. 00. 13'79
7.
4
B. HALFORD LOTUS CLIMAX 16     2. 00. 22'99
8.
10
C. BRISTOW COOPER BORGWARD T.45
29 laps
9.
8
I. BUEB COOPER BORGWARD T.45
29 laps
10.
6
T. PARNELL COOPER CLIMAX T.45
29 laps
11.
30
E. BERNEY COOPER CLIMAX T.45
28 laps
12.
2
I. BURGESS COOPER CLIMAX T.45
28 laps
Fastest lap:   J. LEWIS,   COOPER CLIMAX T45,   on lap 19,   3.48'21
Retired:
 
10
H. TAYLOR COOPER CLIMAX T.45
28 laps
 
42
M. GREGORY COOPER CLIMAX T.51
26 laps
 
44
O. GENDEBIEN COOPER CLIMAX T.51
24 laps
 
20
H. SCHELL COOPER CLIMAX T.45
24 laps
 
18
J. CAMPBELL-JONES COOPER CLIMAX T.45         21 laps
 
26
C. de BEAUFORT PORSCHE RSK
15 laps
 
36
R. HICKS LOTUS CLIMAX 12
12 laps
 
22
T. MARSH COOPER CLIMAX T.45
5 laps
 
46
A. PILLETTE COOPER CLIMAX T.45
2 laps

CHARADE SAYINGS

  • In a remarkable co-incidence the top six cars in this race were the same as the top six at Rouen. Only the order was different.
  • One driver was different however, because Behra drove his own car rather than Herrmann.
  • There were no excuses from Moss. Rarely is he beaten fair and square but he certainly was this time.
  • Cooper have promised to examine the handling deficiencies that afflicted most of their cars but tyres are suspected.
  • The Walker team were not able to get to the bottom of Trintignant's bottoming problems but are determined to sort the car out before the next race.
  • In the few laps that it took Graham Hill to get ahead of Trintignant by which time the two leaders were out of sight but Graham drove a beautiful race in 3rd place.
  • Although he was lapped, Tim Parnell was another who drove splendidly. His best race of the season.
  • The F.2 cars now move west to Rouen for a second major international event in France.

    Back to my home page.